Difficult for a couple to commit to each other when they hardly know each other. The author did a nice job of working thru their insecurities and emotions.

The author obviously has talent as a writer. Her words flow effortlessly however the story lacked intrigue and imagination. For young girls under the age of 15 this book might suffice however I was waiting for a twist a turn at anything to captivate my interest. For instance if sophie and joe didn’t marry to fast and perhaps charity came back divorced realizing joe was the one for her and seeing her again tempted him back into her arms. Then maybe joes brothers come back for the holidays and it’s love at first sight for sophie and Sam but they don’t want to act on their feelings etc. Anything but the straight on story that took place would have elevated this book by far. The writer has the talent but needs to use her imagination more. Think Legends of the fall with brad Pitt great movie twists and turns to keep you interested.

One of the best books I have ever read, read the book almost in an entire day! I loved it. I am originally from Ohio, and moved to Montana to meet my husband. He’s now my ex but Montana will always hold a special place in my heart. Would love to read the entire series.

Such a good read! I wish there were more about Sophie and Joe.. I need to know more! How many kids do they end up having? How does their love blossom after the wedding? I want more!! Love this couple.

Amazing book love the romantics in their relationship but then also the hard ships lovely such an amazing idea!

Enjoyable read while at the gym

I loved this book!

WOW! What a powerful love story! It’s no wonder this author is so highly esteemed- if she were a soldier, she would be standing next to Audey Murphey Eshel Travis

I love this story and the characters.

I was all bummed after finishing ‘The Lost Sheenan’s Bride’, believing there were no more Jane Porter novels involving the families of Marietta and Paradise Valley MT! I quickly discovered there is a whole ‘nother family of books…about the Wyatt brothers!!! As always, I wish it were longer, as I finished it in just one day. But now I’m on to book #2 in the Wyatt brothers’ saga! Yippee!!! 🤓♥️♥️♥️